Apple Mail signatures live in its Signatures settings, and there's one setting worth turning off before you paste.
Updated August 2026
Note: Use Firefox or Chrome (not Safari) when copying your signature to keep the formatting intact. If it looks wrong right after pasting, don't worry - compose a new email and it will display correctly.
Check that "Always match my default message font" is unchecked in Signatures settings before pasting - if it's on, Apple Mail overrides your signature's fonts and colors with the default compose font.
Yes. In Signatures settings, select the account in the left sidebar before creating or choosing a signature - each account can have its own.
This is a known Apple Mail preview quirk - the Signatures window doesn't always render pasted HTML correctly. Close Settings and compose a new email; the signature displays correctly there.
By default Apple Mail uses the same signature everywhere unless you set it to "None" or pick a specific one per account - there's no separate reply/forward toggle like Gmail or Outlook have.
No - iOS Mail has its own signature setting and doesn't accept a direct HTML paste. See our iPhone & iPad signature guide for those separate steps.
Build one free in the Mail Ink editor, then come back and follow the steps above.
Create your free signature